Underdog Pick’em Plays: Week 6

by Cornhole God · Prop Plays

In this weekly series, I’ll outline my five favorite picks for the Sunday slate and provide a sample slip. As always, mix up the combinations and sacrifice a lamb or two.

Week 6 Underdog Pick’em Plays

Underdog Fantasy Week 6 Pick’em Slip

Travis Kelce OVER 86.5 Rec Yds

Confidence Level: Higher than high

Kansas City is coming for redemption with a staggering 30.75 implied team total and Travis Kelce will undoubtedly be a driving force behind their success. Kelce has an impressive 23.1-percent (No. 4 among qualified TEs) Target Share, turning this opportunity into 10 targets last week against Buffalo. Moreover, these targets have translated into elite production this season, displayed by his 30 (No. 1) receptions and 183 (No. 1) yards after catch.

Washington allows 293.4 passing yards per game, so it’s a lock that Kelce, the top-option for Patrick Mahomes, will get his in a bounce back game this weekend.

Mike Gesicki OVER 44.5 Rec Yds

Confidence Level: High

Take the over on a wide receiver who is masked as a tight end. Mike Gesicki’s position-leading 133 Slot Snaps and 140 (No. 6) Routes Run are metrics indicative of a wide receiver, not a tight end. Additionally, his 17.0-percent (No. 2) Hog Rate means that he is receiving a high Target Rate in relation to his Snap Share. Therefore, when this “TE” is on the field, he is being utilized in the passing game more often than not.

Smash the over on Mike Gesicki OVER 44.5 receiving yards in a cake matchup against the hapless Jaguars.

Mac Jones OVER 264.5 Pass Yds

Confidence Level: High

Vegas projects the Patriots and the Cowboys matchup to be high scoring and competitive, with a 51.5 over and the Cowboys being only a 3.5 point favorite. As a result, Mac Jones and the Patriots will look to move the ball through the air against a Cowboys defense that has allowed the second-most passing yards through Week 5. And throwing the ball isn’t out of the ordinary for Mac Jones, exhibited by a 38.4 (No. 9) Team Pass Plays Per Game average. Jones has also been fairly productive, with 742 (No. 12) Completed Air Yards and an excellent 8.2 (No. 1) Accuracy Rating. I expect this to be a sneaky shootout, which is why I’m taking the over on 264.5 passing yards for Mac Jones.

Jakobi Meyers OVER 62.5 Rec Yds

Confidence Level: Medium

Correlation pick No. 1: Jakobi Meyers, the top-receiving option for Mac Jones.

Jakobi Meyers has the opportunity and volume with a 93.6-percent (No. 6) Snap Share and a 24.6-percent (No. 20) Target Share to crush the 62.5 receiving yards line on Underdog Fantasy. On top of this, Meyers will be facing off against subpar cornerback Jourdan Lewis. Lewis has a +15.1 (No. 101) Coverage Rating, meaning that he is targeted frequently by opposing quarterbacks and he is unable to effectively break up or intercept these targets.

No. 1 passing option + below average defender = 🔨

Jonnu Smith OVER 17.5 Rec Yds

Confidence Level: Medium

Correlation pick No. 2: Jonnu Smith – underrated Target Rate.

Jonnu Smith Advanced Stats & Metrics Profile

While Smith’s 54.8-percent (No. 34) Snap Share and 12.3-percent (No. 21) Target Share (No. 21) underwhelm, his 35.9-percent (No. 1) Target Rate is impressive. Essentially, he receives about one target for every three routes run. Add in the fact that he has some of the most explosive workout metrics for a TE, and the result is a low-risk correlation pick for a player that can turn a little into a lot.


I will recap my achievements and shortcomings for last week’s slip at the end of each article.


Week 4 Recap

Hit Rate: 2/5

Joe Burrow UNDER 273.5 Pass Yds ❌

Joe Burrow, Week 5, Underdog Fantasy

Overtime and missed field goals killed this pick. It was great to see Joe Burrow with less than 273.5 passing yards in regulation, but a missed field goal from both Mason Crosby and Evan McPherson sent this game to OT, shooting me down from cloud nine.

A.J. Brown OVER 65.5 Rec Yds ❌

A.J. Brown, Week 5, Underdog Fantasy

It was certainly wishful thinking to believe that A.J. Brown would come back from a lower body injury and return to his normal role. Prior to his injury, he was averaging a 36 routes and 8.5 targets per game. In Week 5, he managed only 22 routes and 6 targets. This performance will hopefully teach me a lesson in fading the over on players returning from injury.

Laviska Shenault OVER 56.5 Rec Yds ✔️

Laviska Shenault, Week 5, Underdog Fantasy

This pick hit for all the wrong reasons. I touted Laviska Shenault because I believed that he would receive a bump in targets with the absence of D.J. Chark. However, his 6.75 targets per game through Week 4 dropped to three targets in Week 5. His lone reception of 58 yards bailed me out of this one.

Tony Pollard OVER 50.5 Rush + Rec Yds ✔️

Tony Pollard, Week 5, Underdog Fantasy

Now this was the pick that truly showcased my brilliance. Indeed, the Cowboys ran a high number of run plays and Tony Pollard benefitted with a season high 14 carries and 4 targets. Moving forward, I’ll continue to hit the over on Pollard when the Cowboys have a high implied team total and when their opponent is projected to trail by a considerable margin.

Justin Herbert UNDER 292.5 Pass Yds ❌

Justin Herbert, Week 5, Underdog Fantasy

Lesson learned: Elite quarterbacks are defense proof.