Transaction Implication: Sam Darnold Traded To The Panthers

by Aaron Stewart · NFL

After watching the San Francisco 49ers pay the price for the third overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft that the Carolina Panthers wouldn’t, and with Deshaun Watson no longer remaining a desirable trade option due to ongoing legal problems, the Panthers settled for Plan C and packaged multiple picks for Sam Darnold. The Panthers sent a 2022 second, a 2022 fourth, and a 2021 sixth-round pick to the New York Jets to secure the services of the NFL’s resident Cole Sear.

Will he continue to see ghosts or can he take advantage of the second chance provided by the Panthers? What does comparable historical trade compensation say about his franchise quarterback upside? Is the “Adam Gase Effect” a coach-centric narrative or is there support from the advanced stats and metrics to show why players succeed after leaving Gase-coached teams? In dynasty, what are we doing with Darnold and new weapons D.J. Moore and Robby Anderson?


The Contract

Sam Darnold‘s fifth-year option was exercised by the Carolina Panthers when they acquired him. This guarantees his $18.86 million salary for 2022, giving him two seasons in Carolina to get his career as a starting quarterback back on track.

Sam Darnold’s Contract via Spotrac

Despite picking up Darnold’s fifth-year option, the team’s commitment to him as the starter may be brusque. Almost two years ago, the Miami Dolphins acquired a former first-round quarterback in Josh Rosen for a second and a fifth-round pick. That trade compensation resembles what the Panthers gave up for Darnold.

The Dolphins acted quickly and replaced Rosen the following year in the draft when he fizzled. It’s no secret that Panthers owner David Tepper covets acquiring a franchise quarterback. If Darnold and his league-worst among qualified quarterbacks -67.40 EPA does not improve in his new destination, expect the Panthers to follow Miami’s lead and move on as soon as possible.

Sam Darnold, Robby Anderson and “The Adam Gase Effect”

Damien Williams. Kenyan Drake. DeVante Parker. Ryan Tannehill. Robby Anderson. Is it a coincidence that players that escape the hoosegow of Adam Gase-led franchises immediately turn their careers around? The Fantasy Football Colossus will fire me if I make coach-centric statements, so instead let’s pivot to the advanced stats.

Anderson was pigeonholed into the vertical, deep-threat role when he entered the league after blazing a 4.41 (91st-percentile) 40-Yard Dash. In his final season in New York, he averaged 10.0 (No. 54) Fantasy Points per Game with a 15.2 (No. 8) Average Target Distance. It was assumed that would be his role in Carolina last season, while D.J. Moore would be utilized in the slot and on short-to-intermediate routes. How’s that saying go when people assume?

Anderson’s 205 (No. 37) Slot Snaps were almost twice as many as Moore’s 128 (No. 70), and his 9.6 (No. 64) Average Target Distance was a far cry from his 2019 average. Across the formation, Moore saw his Average Target Distance increase from 11.3 (No. 53) in 2019 to 13.4 (No. 21) in 2020. In his new role, Anderson secured a 26.1-percent (No. 6) Target Share, 25.0-percent (No. 10) Red Zone Target Share, and 17.8-percent (No. 6) Hog Rate. Anderson would finish 2020 averaging 13.8 (No. 30) Fantasy Points per Game. Though only scoring three (No. 65) Total Touchdowns prevented greater fantasy success.

Jamison Crowder’s Strong Start to 2020

What is the significance of Anderson’s role change when he joined the Panthers offense? Sam Darnold has a knack for preferring his short-distance options to his deep targets. When Anderson was on the Jets in 2019, it was Jamison Crowder that finished as the better fantasy option averaging 12.4 (No. 36) Fantasy Points per Game, with an 8.0 (No. 91) Average Target Distance. Crowder has finished with back-to-back top-10 seasons in Red Zone Target Share. In 2019, he had a 24.7-percent (No. 14) Target Share with a 16.0-percent (No. 15) Hog Rate. He started last season with three consecutive games of 10-plus targets, seven-plus receptions, and 100-plus receiving yards.

Dynasty Impact

PlayerProfiler’s Trade Finder tool helps dynasty football managers price gauge the players they show interest in. Robby Anderson‘s trade value flummoxes me.

Robby Anderson Trade Analyzer

He finished last season with 95 (No. 8) Receptions and 1,088 (No. 13) Receiving Yards. And yet, someone traded him away for *checks notes* a third-round rookie pick in 2021? PlayerProfiler has 24-year-old D’Wayne Eskridge slotted to go in the middle of the third round in rookie drafts. Anderson was 24 years old during his second NFL season back in 2017 and scored 200 points on the dot that season to register an NFL breakout according to Breakout Finder. Why draft a rookie hoping he has an Anderson-level season in his career when Anderson, coming off a career season, will turn 28 years old?

The Allure of the Mystery Box

Sam Darnold should be traded if fantasy football managers can capitalize on the perception of his increased dynasty value. The parallels of the trade compensations for Darnold and Josh Rosen are alarming. On top of that, what upside does Darnold have in fantasy football? Not only does he offer nothing in the running game by averaging 3.1 (No. 27) Carries per Game in 2020 and registering one (No. 44) Red Zone Carry. But his lack of mobility contributed to a 34.4-percent (No. 28) Pressured Completion Percentage despite 1.62 (No. 13) Receiver Target Separation mark.

Friend of the Underworld Ian Hartitz hit the nail on the head about D.J. Moore. Despite a 41.6-percent (No. 2) Air Yards Share and 1,575 (No. 5) Air Yards, Moore disappointed in fantasy football last season. His 10 (No. 2) Drops is partially to blame. But it’s mostly due to a porous 70.3 (No. 98) QB Rating When Targeted, 6.89 (No. 83) Target Accuracy mark, and a 73.7-percent (No. 77) Catchable Target Rate.

2021 Vacated Targets via NBC Sports Edge

With Curtis Samuel vacating 97 (No. 37) Targets, and taking into account Moore’s 757 (No. 8) Unrealized Air Yards, there are opportunities in the Panthers 2021 offense for more production for Moore. His 2.27 (No. 12) Yards Per Route Run, +68.7 (No. 11) EPA, and 28.1-percent (No. 13) Dominator Rating displayed elite efficiency that can translate to a fantasy football bounceback in 2021.