J.J. McCarthy became notorious for throwing scattershot, direct-line darts on his way to posting 13.7 Fantasy Points Per Game (No. 25 among qualified quarterbacks) and an equally putrid 6.7 Yards Per Attempt in 2025.

McCarthy has been working with private throwing coach John Beck to improve his touch and accuracy, as well as timing and footwork. If Beck’s instruction has a positive effect, McCarthy will push Kyler Murray for the starting job. Lewis offered a ray of hope based on how “McCarthy shows up to work every day” and believes he can “lift the tide for the entire team.”

This is a make-or-break season for McCarthy and his college championship pedigree. From Sam Darnold to Baker Mayfield, quarterbacks with Top-10 draft capital have come back from the dead before. He is worth a late-round dart throw in fantasy football superflex and 2 QB leagues.