Sportsbook Rankings vs. ECR Wars | Week 11

by Elliott Troop · Betting & Props

Week 11 is here. This week’s schedule can be described as GTA VI-friendly, with multiple games featuring double-digit point spreads. But who are we kidding? We will be glued to our screens watching the likes of Chig Okonkwo, Keenan Allen, and Pat Freiermuth try to guide us towards the promised land of the fantasy football playoffs. 

The premise of this article is simple. We pit sportsbook rankings vs. expert consensus rankings on a week-to-week basis. 

Before we jump into this week’s players, let’s take a moment to review last week. I highlighted these players: 

Jordan Love – experts win

Jonathan Taylor – experts win

Parker Washington – experts win

Darren Waller – sportsbooks win 

Standings:

Sportsbooks: 4

Experts: 4

Tie: 2

We’re all squared up heading into the home straight.

PlayerProfiler is home to award-winning dynasty rankings and tools. Our Dynasty Deluxe package includes complete Dynasty Rankings, Rookie Rankings, Trade Analyzer, Draft Planner, Mock Drafts, and more. Check it out!


Sportsbook Rankings vs Expert Consensus Rankings | Week 11

Brock Purdy | QB, San Francisco 49ers

Sportsbook Ranks: QB5

Expert Rank: QB10

Last week, the sportsbooks ranked Jordan Love as the QB8. That was a bigger mistake than the Lions’ Human Centipede touchdown celebration. The Vikings defense dominated the Packers offense, sacking Love eight times as he went on to finish as the QB22 — his worst fantasy finish of the season. In Week 11, the books are going back to a quarterback facing the Vikings defense. This time, it’s Brock Purdy in Mexico City. 

In what could be an NFC Championship preview, the 49ers head into Week 11 as one of the league’s premier offenses. They rank: 

  • 1st in total yards per game (399)
  • 1st in EPA/play (0.18)
  • 1st in EPA/pass (0.29)
  • 1st in pass success (54.9%)
  • 2nd in EPA/rush (0.09)
  • 2nd in PPG (31.2)

That prolific offense gets the league’s stingiest defense. 

  • 1st in blitz rate (72%)
  • 1st in points per game (14)
  • 2nd in total yards allowed (273.3)
  • 2nd in passing yards allowed (161.4)
  • 2nd in EPA/play allowed (-0.18)

There is one key difference between the Packers and 49ers offenses. According to PFF, the 49ers have the second-best offensive line in the league. The Packers rank 32nd. If any team is equipped to combat the Vikings ability to generate pressure, it is the 49ers — and that is reflected in Purdy’s Week 11 rank. 

Meanwhile, the experts are apprehensive about ranking Purdy higher — even though he is playing at a near MVP level — due to the Vikings defense. At this point, there are ten weeks of data saying that expectations should be tempered against Minnesota. The Vikings are giving up just 8.7 fantasy points per game to opposing quarterbacks. Essentially, they are turning opposing quarterbacks into Baker Mayfield (8.5 fantasy points per game).

Jonah Coleman | RB, Denver Broncos

Sportsbook Ranks: RB6

Expert Rank: RB15

Outside of Jeremiyah Love, this running back class was largely perceived to be bereft of depth and talent. That hasn’t been the case. While Love is currently on IR, Emmett Johnson, Kaelon Black and Jonah Coleman have all carved out legitimate roles. We will stick with Jonah Coleman here. 

Jonah Coleman’s Advanced Metrics

In four games in which he has recorded at least one carry, Coleman averages 15.7 PPR fantasy points per game. That would be good for the RB14 on the season. Coleman has a Thanos-like grip on the Broncos’ RB1 job, comfortably beating out RJ Harvey and J.K. Dobbins. In Week 11, Coleman’s stock could reach an all time high. 

The Broncos face the Raiders. Over the course of the season, the Raiders have implemented a strict all-you-can-eat policy for every opposing running back. This run defense is less ‘bend, don’t break’ and more ‘please, I insist’. The Raiders are giving up 151 rushing yards per game, which ranks as the second-most in the league. They’re also giving up the third-most fantasy points to opposing running backs. Coleman has the eighth-highest rushing-yard total in Week 11 (67.5) and has a receptions total of 3.5 (tied-fourth of all running backs). If you want to go one step further, the sportsbooks have Dobbins ranked as the RB27 for the week, while the experts have him ranked 38th. 

The experts are a little less optimistic about Coleman in Week 11, though they still think he will finish as a high-end RB2. Perhaps that’s from years of watching Sean Payton mercilessly destroy our fantasy football dreams.

Carnell Tate | WR, Tennessee Titans

Sportsbook Ranks: WR12

Expert Rank: WR24

We haven’t seen Carnell Tate for three weeks. We also haven’t really seen his talent reflected in big box scores yet. That is due to some poor early-season quarterback play courtesy of Cam Ward. If we pop up the hood of the car, we can see a lot of encouraging signs. Tate ranks 15th among all wide receivers in target share (26%) and fourth in air yard share (45%). 

With Wan’Dale Robinson being placed on IR, the stars are aligning for a Tate breakout game against a Cowboys defense that puts the over in cover 2. Through 10 weeks, the Cowboys are giving up a league-high 393.8 yards per game and the third-most points per game (28.2). 

Combine those egregious defensive metrics with some improved quarterback play from Ward and, baby, we got ourselves a stew cooking. The books have Tate ranked as a low-end WR1 on the week. Tate’s receiving-yard total ranks tenth among all wide receivers (65.5) and tied-fourth in receptions (5.5). 

Despite the plus matchup, the experts don’t agree with the aggressive Tate ranking — and for good reason. Two sunny days do not make a summer, nor do two good performances make a season. Ward still ranks 32nd among 37 qualifying quarterbacks (min 100 dropbacks) in both EPA/pass and pass success rate.

Mark Andrews | TE, Baltimore Ravens

Sportsbook Ranks: TE7

Expert Rank: TE14

Ahh, Mark Andrews. A man responsible for more bad drops than Drake after a breakup. If you saw Monday Night Football, you will have seen that Andrews is back. According to the broadcast, Andrews had been playing with a broken hand since Week 3. Thanks for telling us now, but that doesn’t explain the last three seasons. Well, the hand is now healed, and he’s playing with Jacoby ‘I only pass to tight ends’ Brissett.

Brissett immediately leaned on Andrews, giving him eight targets in his Baltimore debut. The veteran tight end caught all eight for 82 receiving yards, both season highs.


The sportsbooks are expecting Andrews to continue to be a focal point of this Ravens offense. His reception line sits at 4.5, with his receiving-yard line at 35.5. The experts are a little more hesitant to proclaim the return of Andrews, presumably due to his proclivity to drop anything that heads in his general direction. The Panthers have given up just 12.5 fantasy points per game to tight ends, which ranks 20th among all teams.


Elliott Troop is a fantasy football analyst for PlayerProfiler.

For more articles from PlayerProfiler, check out the fantasy home page – NFL Fantasy | PlayerProfiler – Fantasy Football News & Media