The Keenan Allen signing gives Indianapolis a proven target earner on a one year, $8.32 million deal. Allen commanded 122 targets in 2025 for 81 receptions and 777 yards, while posting a 22.6% Target Share and 1.72 Yards Per Route Run.

Allen is back in the fantasy conversation, but the lack of a true field stretcher could put a ceiling on this passing attack. Allen’s 8.4-yard ADOT and 20% Deep Target Share make him another underneath option alongside Tyler Warren and Josh Downs, not a replacement for Alec Pierce’s vertical role. Warren already earned a 21.2% Target Share in 2025, while Downs posted a 17.5% share, so the Colts are creating a crowded ecosystem for short area targets.